98 pts - Wine Advocate
A sensational effort, Tertre Roteboeuf’s 2005, along with the 2000, is one of the most profound wines made by Francois Mitjavile. A dense ruby/purple color is followed by a stunning perfume of sweet black currants, jammy cherries, licorice, and spice. Full-bodied and opulent with high, but remarkably sweet, velvety tannins as well as a stunning texture and a finish that lasts nearly a minute, this prodigious St.-Emilion should be drinkable in 3-4 years, and last for two decades or more. Kudos to the proprietor. - WA, RP (4/2008)
92-95 pts - Wine Spectator
Beautiful fruit with a Burgundian style. Pure and aromatic. Full-bodied, with gorgeous fruit and a long, long finish. Seductive. This is a fascinating and cerebral wine that wows you with its beauty. This could easily move up to a classic rating. Score Range: 92-95 — JS (06/2006)
94 pts - Vinous
Good bright medium ruby. Sexy, superripe aromas of raspberry, smoked meat, mocha, chocolate and resiny oak. Then explosively fruity in the mouth, offering great sucrosite leavened by racy acidity. The alcohol is close to 15% but the impression is of brilliant black raspberry and dark cherry fruit and great energy. Finishes with very broad tannins and strong chocolate and coffee notes. Utterly distinctive wine. ST