94 pts - Wine Advocate
The 2012 Chardonnay Durell Vineyard offers up plenty of tropical pineapple and more of the orange marmalade and citrus oil notes in a full, deep and fleshier style than the McCrea. Its touch of wet rocks and its good acidity and precision give the wine a well-defined style. It should drink well for 4-5 years. - eRobertParker.com, RP (1/2015)
92 pts - Vinous
The 2012 Chardonnay Durell Vineyard is one of the most open and accessible of Kistler's vineyard-designate Chardonnays. Orange peel, hazelnut, smoke, mint and anise blossom in the glass. There is lovely resonance and richness here, but all in the mid-weight, open style of the year.- Antonio Galloni (01/2015)