89 pts - Wine Advocate
91 pts - Wine Spectator
Rich in cherry flavor, with hints of earth and spice. Firm and elegant, with all its components well-proportioned. Really lingers on the finish, with a lasting impression of ripe fruit. Drink now through 2012. 1,600 cases made, 150 cases imported. — BS (05/2005)
94 pts - Burghound
As it almost always is in its youth, this is a linear wine but the '02 ratchets up the minerality and that sense of almost exacting precision and detail. The tannins are not quite as firm as those of the Taillepieds yet here there is another level of elegance and purity with absolutely perfect harmony and a subtle, understated, almost Zen-like reserve. In short, this is a classic Clos des Ducs that will rival such memorable vintages as 1978, 1985, 1991 1993, 1996 and 1999. If you love Clos des Ducs, don't miss the '02 BH
92 pts - Vinous
Harvested 19th-24th September: A very distinctive nose of spice and cinnamon. The fruit is gorgeous, very round. This is a really harmonious well-balanced wine with a silky, supple mouth coating texture. Drinking beautifully now, I expect the 22 will hold for years because of its balance.- Jay McInerney (12/216)