92 pts - Wine Advocate
The Wine Advocate (May 2018): 92+ Points. “The 2004 Monte Bello opens in the glass with classic aromas of cigar box, spice and crushed red and black currant fruit, revealing little obvious trace of its time in new oak. On the palate, it’s medium to full-bodied but still quite tightly wound, with a firm chassis of fine-grained tannins and a bright line of acidity that seem to demand further cellaring. I suspect it’s in a somewhat withdrawn phase between youth and maturity. That said, the 2004 isn’t as structured as another backward vintage, the 2006, nor do I believe it possesses as much potential for positive evolution.” – William Kelley
93 pts - Vinous
Vinous Media (July 2014): “Readers looking for a Monte Bello that is ready to drink should consider the 2004. Just beginning to enter its early plateau of maturity, the 2004 is in a beautiful spot right now. Sweet tobacco, smoke, cedar, licorice and leather meld into a core of dark fruit. The 2004 won’t last forever, but it does have enough depth to age beautifully for the another decade, perhaps more. A distinctly floral/savory finish rounds things out nicely.” -Antonio Galloni (Rated: 93)